RE: filmscanners: Need feedback on VueScan Improvements

["shAf" <michael@shaffer.net>]

Jules writes ...

> > I think many on the list would vote for a separate
> checkbox control to
> > enable grain removal independently of the
> clean/scrub/scour setting.
>
> but scrub = clean + grain removal
> and
> scour = clean + heavier grain removal
>
> why would you want to seperate these?  to allow the option of grain
> removal WITHOUT clean?

        Presumably Ed's implimentation of "dust removal" would be an on/off
switch, and the implimentation of "grain removal" would be a pull down
list.  I imagine this might cater to less confusion, and possibly
those who simply do not want to throw another filter at they're data
if they choose some degree of grain removal.  I am with you, and find
Ed's dust removal via IR so innocuous I use it all the time ... it
doesn't bother me that its also part of grain removal.

shAf  :o)